A Heritage Denied Decades of official discrimination
have turned Malaysia's ethnic Indians into a disgruntled underclass
By anthony spaeth
Return of the Megaprojects
Multiracial malaysia has three heritages to celebrate: Malay, Chinese
and Indian. In the Bujang Valley in northern Kedah state, Malaysia's
Indian roots are visible. An ancient kingdom existed there, of Hindu
and Buddhist beliefs, dating back to the 4th century. It was a trading
and migration port, within sailing distance of India, and it eventually
became part of Sumatra's mighty Sriwijaya Empire. Since the site was
rediscovered by explorers in the 1930s, more than 50 temple ruins have
been excavated in the valley, making it Malaysia's richest archaeological
But an Indian Malaysian visiting the Bujang Valley might come away feeling
demeaned rather than proud-and that would be no accident. The government
has spruced up some ruins and built a museum beside them to showcase
Bujang's archaeological finds. The ochre ruins are classically Indian
in design, neat, dull-and there is nothing to tell the visitor how grand
the originals may have
been. The museum has Buddhist and Hindu statues behind glass-cows, Ganeshas,
lingams-but the official literature does its best to downplay, even
denigrate, the Indian impact on the region. A board on the museum wall
describes an "old Malay kingdom" in the Bujang Valley that
had "contact with various people of different cultural origins
and environments." The museum's brochure is even more explicit.
It states that maritime trade led to the "indianization" of
the Bujang Valley. The indigenous culture, it says "was eventually
If that sounds like a wan cheer for Malaysia's Indian heritage, it's
a sentiment familiar to most of the country's 1.8 million people of
Indian descent. Affirmative action-type quotas for the Malay population,
along with a political system controlled by the Malays and Chinese,
make many Indian Malaysians feel like third-class citizens. The result
is an increasingly aggrieved population, and a
timid one, that isn't very happy about its place in society. "I'm
not sure I can see a future in this country for my children," says
an Indian-Malaysian businesswoman in Kuala Lumpur who asks not to be
named. "We'll give it another few years. If things have not improved,
we'll leave for Europe."
Race is the big divide in Malaysia, as it has been ever since the watershed
race riots of 1969. In his 20 years in power, Prime Minister Mahathir
Mohamad has tried to uplift the Malays, who make up 55% of the 22 million
population, and guarantee them a large percentage of available business
opportunities. The second-largest group, the Chinese, were supposed
to lose their disproportionate grip on the country's economy. But it
may be the Indians who were the real losers. Most were imported a century
ago to work the rubber plantations and tin mines, and they still dominate
the bottom rungs of the social ladder. "Indians have neither the
political nor the economic leverage to break out of their vicious cycle
of poverty," says Selvakumaran Ramachandran, an Indian-Malaysian
academic who works for the United Nations Development Program. "If
their problems are not arrested and reversed, it is almost certain they
will emerge as an underclass."
Already, Indians have the lowest share of the nation's corporate wealth:
1.5%, compared to 19.4% for the Malays and 38.5% for the Chinese. Not
surprisingly, Indians claim the highest rate of suicide of any community.
Violent crime is becoming Indian turf. In 1994, 128 of the 377 murders
committed in Malaysia were by Indians. Some 15% of the Indians in the
capital are squatters. "I have a feeling," says P. Ramasamy,
a political science professor at the National University, "that
if something is not done soon, something is going to really blow."
The Indians' main problem is numerical. With only 8% of the country's
population, they don't have enough clout to alter pro-Malay business
or employment policies, or even stand up to Malay chauvinism of the
sort exhibited at the Bujang Valley museum. The Chinese community has
a slew of ambitious political leaders. The Indian community's politics
are dominated by the Malaysian Indian Congress (mic) and its leader
of more than two decades, S. Samy Vellu, who happens to be the only
Indian in Mahathir's cabinet.
When the government wants to dispense largesse to the Indian community,
it usually does so through Samy Vellu, as a recent scene at mic headquarters
demonstrated. Indian parents and their children came to hear Samy Vellu
describe a new government scheme for student loans. It was a "very
special allocation" made through the generosity of the Prime Minister
and the Education
Minister, he said. To qualify, families had to earn less than $5,300
a year. A young Indian woman in the crowd admitted that her father made
more than the stipulated amount. "Can I still apply?" she
asked. "Don't worry," Samy Vellu assured her. "Come see
me afterwards and I will make sure you can get it." Obviously impressed
with the minister's magnanimity, the crowd of 500 applauded warmly.
"Whatever we get," says a senior Indian journalist, "we
can get only through the mic. That's how the system works."
One area in which Indians have prospered is the professions, particularly
medicine and law, and Indian names stud the rolls of professional societies.
Many of this group hail from white-collar families who worked in Malaysia
when it was a British colony. Yet even with that background, an Indian
Malaysian can find it difficult to become a doctor or lawyer. Local
university seats and
scholarships to study overseas are all awarded by a racial quota system.
Even when someone gets a degree, discrimination is frequent. Indian
doctors, for instance, complain that they are increasingly excluded
from the lists of approved doctors whom civil servants or company employees
can use. "I wish you Americans would invade-just for a while,"
a small-town Indian doctor tells a visitor. "Then I would have
a fairer chance of working in this country of ours."
So far, Indians have resigned themselves to their plight. But some rumbles
are being heard. Last October, five Malaysian men were attacked and
killed one night in the town of Kampar, 150 km north of Kuala Lumpur.
Their charred remains were found in a torched pickup truck. The police
arrested 13 cattle ranchers of Indian descent. The ranchers had complained
for two years of people poaching their cows, but apparently the local
police had done nothing to help. The 13 ranchers have yet to be tried,
and poaching has reportedly ceased in that area. The defendants are
quietly regarded as heroes among the Indian community. "Malaysia
cannot afford to have about 8% of its population feel alienated,"
warns R.V. Navaratnam, a prominent businessman. "Malaysian unity
can be as strong only as its weakest link-which is the Malaysian Indian
With reporting by Ken Stier/Bujang Valley